The Legacy of Charles Martel & the Battle of Tours — WHE Article Discussion (2-1809)

The Battle of Poitiers aka the Battle of Tours took place over roughly a week in early October of 732. The opposing sides consisted of a Frankish army led by Charles Martel (r. 718-741) against an invading Muslim army under the nominal sovereignty of the Umayyad Caliphate (c. 661-750) based in Damascus, Syria.


This is a companion discussion topic for the original article at https://www.worldhistory.org/article/1809/the-legacy-of-charles-martel--the-battle-of-tours/.


Join the Conversation

  • What did you think about this article?
  • Is there anything you'd change or add?
  • Does this match what you've learned about the topic before?

Is there anything you'd like to ask about this article? Ask away — and if you spot something that should be covered, that's useful to know too.

Possible factual error: the 739 campaign and Dijon

The article states:

“their largest invasion occurred in 739 where they almost reached as far as Dijon before being beaten back by Frankish and Lombard forces.”

I have been unable to find a reliable source for a major Umayyad invasion in 739 that advanced nearly to Dijon.

The surviving accounts associated with 739 instead place Charles Martel’s operations in Provence, particularly around Avignon and Marseille, against Duke Maurontus and his Saracen allies. The Annales Mettenses priores for 739 describes Charles marching into Provence, taking Avignon, traversing Provence to the Mediterranean coast, and reaching Marseille. The Gesta sanctorum patrum Fontanellensis gives essentially the same geography. Neither describes an Umayyad advance toward Dijon.

Sources for the 739 campaign:
Annales Mettenses priores, 739 · Gesta sanctorum patrum Fontanellensis, 739

By contrast, the well-attested deep Muslim raid into Burgundy belongs to the expedition of Anbasa ibn Suhaym al-Kalbi in 725. Philippe Sénac describes that force moving rapidly up the Rhône and Saône into Burgundy and sacking Autun, with traditions extending detachments farther north.

Philippe Sénac, “Présence musulmane en Languedoc. Réalités et vestiges”

So the sentence’s 739 / Dijon chronology appears to conflate distinct campaigns.

If there is a specific source for a large Umayyad invasion in 739 that nearly reached Dijon, I would be very interested to see it. Otherwise, this appears to be a factual error worth correcting.

Welcome, Lance! Thanks for pointing out the error.

I have sent you a message.